We talk a lot about the value of data in farming. Measure it, record it, benchmark it and use it to make management decisions. And generally, I agree, writes Nerys Wright.
But after a particularly frustrating day on farm recently, I found myself asking a different question: what happens when the technology we rely on to collect that data lets us down?
The plan was straightforward. Put sheep through the handling system, collect the information we needed and use it to help make management decisions that would determine the breeding of the flock for the next five years. Except the equipment wouldn’t play ball.
What should have been a useful day became hours spent troubleshooting, repeating jobs and trying to establish whether the problem was us, the hardware, software, settings or something else entirely. The biggest loss wasn’t necessarily the data. It was time and, perhaps more importantly, confidence. 
I am a great believer in using good information. Weights, body condition scores, EID records, health data and FEC results can all help us understand what is happening within a flock and support better decisions.
But every piece of data has a cost. There is the equipment and software, certainly, but also the farmer’s time gathering sheep, putting them through the system, recording information and dealing with it afterwards. And when technology fails, it is usually the farmer left carrying that cost.
Farmers are increasingly encouraged by advisers (like me!), researchers, government and the wider industry to collect more information and embrace data-led farming. Yet on an actual farm there isn’t an IT department standing beside the race when something stops working.
Perhaps we need to hold agricultural technology to account a little more. Before asking farmers to collect another piece of information, we should ask:
- Will it change a decision?
- Is it simple and reliable to collect?
- And when the technology lets them down, who is there to help?
Because if the answer to that final question is the farmer, on their own, in the sheep pens, we haven’t quite cracked data-driven farming yet.
Nerys Wright is an independent sheep consultant. Call 07891 187643 or visit sheepconsultancy.co.uk.

